Why We Oppose Hyperscale Data Centres
We use artificial intelligence within ObjectNow. We also oppose the development of hyperscale data centres. Some people may consider those positions contradictory, so we want to explain why they are not.
There is an enormous difference between using AI as a limited technical assistance tool and constructing vast industrial facilities designed to provide computing capacity on an entirely different scale.
We believe it is important that our followers understand that distinction, particularly as proposals for increasingly large data centres emerge across Scotland and the wider United Kingdom.
For the avoidance of doubt, ObjectNow is 100% opposed to the development of hyperscale data centres of the kind being proposed at Chapelcross, near Annan.
Our opposition is based on concerns about the scale of these developments, their environmental consequences, their demands on energy and infrastructure, and whether the claimed economic benefits adequately justify those impacts.
Firstly, How Does ObjectNow Use AI?
We have always been open about the fact that artificial intelligence has played a role in the development and operation of our platform.
However, our use of AI is considerably more limited than some people might assume.
ObjectNow supports communities responding to major planning applications, including wind farms, battery energy storage facilities, solar developments, electricity transmission infrastructure and other industrial proposals.
These applications frequently involve thousands of pages of Environmental Impact Assessment documentation, technical reports, environmental surveys, planning statements and supporting evidence.
AI can assist us with processing, extracting, organising and examining information contained within these documents.
It is a tool that supports our research, not something that replaces human judgement or independently determines our position on a development.
Our foundation objection material is researched, prepared and reviewed by humans.
Since the beginning of 2026, our public objection letter generator has not used generative AI to create or assemble letters.
Instead, our independently developed platform uses programmed algorithms and structured foundation material to assemble representations according to the issues selected by individual users.
Our transition away from AI-assisted letter generation took place between 2025 and the beginning of 2026, as part of our continuing efforts to improve efficiency, independence and control over our technology.
So, What Is the Difference?
The distinction is one of purpose, scale and infrastructure.
ObjectNow uses AI selectively to assist with specific technical tasks. We do not develop or train large artificial intelligence models, operate industrial computing facilities or provide AI services to millions of customers.
Our use of AI is occasional and task-specific, rather than the continuous operation of large computing systems.
Hyperscale data centres, by comparison, are facilities designed to accommodate substantial computing, storage and networking infrastructure.
Some support cloud computing, business applications and conventional internet services. Others provide infrastructure for artificial intelligence, including the training and operation of increasingly complex models.
These facilities can operate around the clock, with substantial electricity requirements and associated demands for cooling, electrical connections and supporting infrastructure.
Limited Technical Assistance
We use AI selectively to assist with processing and examining technical planning documents.
We do not train large AI models or operate industrial computing facilities.
Our foundation objection material is researched and reviewed by humans, while our letter generator operates without generative AI.
Industrial Computing Facilities
Hyperscale data centres provide substantial computing, storage and networking capacity.
They can support cloud services, commercial applications and AI model training or operation.
Their operation can involve significant electricity consumption, cooling requirements and associated infrastructure.
It is important to recognise that not every hyperscale data centre is exclusively an AI facility, and not every AI interaction requires a new hyperscale development.
Nevertheless, the rapid expansion of AI services is one of the factors contributing to growing demand for large-scale computing infrastructure.
Our limited use of AI does not mean that we support every form of infrastructure associated with the technology.
We can recognise that AI has practical applications while questioning whether the environmental and social costs of expanding industrial computing capacity are justified.
Why Are We Opposed to Hyperscale Data Centres?
Energy Consumption and Grid Capacity
One of our principal concerns is the electricity required to operate these facilities.
Large data centres can place substantial additional demand on electricity networks, potentially requiring new substations, transmission infrastructure, grid reinforcement and additional generating capacity.
These are not insignificant considerations, particularly in areas where communities are already experiencing extensive renewable energy and electricity transmission development.
Scotland is seeing proposals for wind farms, solar developments, battery storage facilities, substations and transmission lines, often accompanied by claims about their contribution to national energy security and decarbonisation.
We believe it is entirely reasonable to question whether the expansion of energy-intensive computing infrastructure could create further demand for electricity and associated developments.
Developers should be required to explain the anticipated electricity consumption of their facilities, how that demand will be supplied, the implications for grid infrastructure and the resulting environmental impacts.
Claims that a development will use renewable electricity should also be examined carefully.
Purchasing renewable electricity through contractual arrangements does not, by itself, demonstrate that a facility will have no effect on electricity demand, grid capacity or the wider energy system.
Environmental Impacts
Hyperscale data centres are major industrial developments.
Depending on their design and location, they can involve extensive land take, large buildings, cooling equipment, electrical infrastructure, backup power systems, security installations and substantial construction activity.
Their environmental effects can extend beyond the boundaries of the development itself.
Potential issues include landscape and visual impacts, biodiversity loss, habitat fragmentation, construction emissions, noise, water consumption and the cumulative effects of associated infrastructure.
Cooling systems are a particular consideration.
Some data centres use water-intensive cooling arrangements, while others rely on air cooling, closed-loop systems or alternative technologies.
The actual impacts depend on the cooling technology, local water availability, operating conditions and the design of the facility.
We therefore believe that developers must provide clear, independently assessable information about their proposed cooling systems, anticipated resource consumption and environmental effects.
These matters should not be dismissed simply because a development is described as technologically advanced or economically important.
Carbon Emissions and Sustainability
We are also concerned about the wider carbon implications of constructing and operating enormous computing facilities.
Electricity consumption is only one part of the equation.
The construction of large industrial buildings, manufacture of computing equipment, production of concrete and steel, installation of electrical infrastructure and eventual replacement of hardware all contribute to a development’s environmental footprint.
The environmental consequences of manufacturing and disposing of computing equipment must also be considered.
We believe developers should provide credible whole-life carbon assessments rather than relying primarily on operational energy claims.
If a development is presented as sustainable, those claims should be supported by transparent evidence covering construction, operation, equipment replacement and eventual decommissioning.
Economic Benefits and Local Employment
We frequently see major industrial developments promoted through promises of investment, economic growth and employment.
However, there is an important distinction between temporary construction employment and permanent operational jobs.
Hyperscale data centres can require substantial workforces during construction, but their ongoing operation is highly automated compared with many traditional industrial facilities.
The number and quality of permanent jobs therefore deserve careful scrutiny.
Communities should be given clear information about how many positions will be created, how many will be permanent, what skills will be required and how much of the economic benefit will remain locally.
Headline investment figures should not be treated as equivalent to direct economic benefits for surrounding communities.
Nor should the promise of substantial private investment automatically outweigh legitimate concerns about environmental impacts and infrastructure demands.
Who Actually Benefits?
This is one of the questions we believe deserves far greater attention.
The expansion of hyperscale computing infrastructure is being driven by a combination of cloud computing demand, digital services, commercial data processing and the rapid growth of artificial intelligence.
Many of the companies involved are among the largest and most financially powerful technology businesses in the world.
There are undoubtedly commercial benefits associated with providing additional computing capacity.
However, commercial demand does not automatically establish that a particular development is necessary, appropriately located or environmentally acceptable.
We are concerned that communities could be expected to accommodate substantial industrial infrastructure while the principal financial benefits accrue to major technology companies and their investors.
We believe the balance between private commercial benefit and public environmental cost requires considerably greater scrutiny.
What About Chapelcross, Near Annan?
The proposed hyperscale data centre development at Chapelcross is particularly relevant to our concerns.
Dumfries and Galloway is already facing considerable pressure from proposed energy and infrastructure developments.
We believe any proposal to introduce a major new source of industrial electricity demand must be examined alongside its associated infrastructure requirements and cumulative environmental consequences.
In particular, we want to see clear evidence establishing the proposed development’s electricity requirements, anticipated grid connections, cooling arrangements, carbon footprint, permanent employment benefits and wider environmental implications.
We also believe that the justification for a development of this scale should be open to meaningful public scrutiny.
It is not enough simply to suggest that the growth of artificial intelligence means more data centres must be constructed.
The need for a particular facility, at a particular location and on a particular scale, should be supported by credible evidence.
Are We Against All Technology?
Absolutely not.
ObjectNow itself demonstrates how technology can help communities participate more effectively in planning processes.
We have developed our own objection platform, document-processing systems and Horivane, our independently developed 3D wind farm visualisation technology.
We understand the benefits of technological innovation.
However, supporting useful technology does not require unquestioning support for every industrial development associated with it.
The same principle applies to artificial intelligence.
We can recognise that AI has useful applications in research, accessibility, document processing and other areas while opposing the construction of enormous industrial facilities whose environmental and infrastructure impacts we consider unacceptable.
Our position is not that all computing should stop or that every existing data centre is unnecessary.
Our opposition concerns the expansion of hyperscale developments and the scale of the environmental and infrastructure consequences they can create.
We Also Recognise Our Own Responsibilities
It would be misleading for us to suggest that our own technology has no environmental footprint.
Our website, hosting infrastructure and occasional use of external AI services all require computing resources.
When we use an external AI service, the processing takes place on infrastructure operated by that service or its providers.
We therefore recognise that even relatively limited AI usage contributes to demand for computing resources.
The distinction we are making is not that ObjectNow’s technology operates without environmental consequences.
It is that the scale and purpose of our operations are fundamentally different from those of companies developing and operating hyperscale computing infrastructure.
We have already taken steps to reduce our reliance on AI, including removing generative AI from public objection letter generation.
We will continue examining ways to make our systems more efficient and reduce unnecessary computing demands.
We believe that organisations should take responsibility for their own use of technology while remaining entitled to scrutinise the environmental consequences of major industrial developments.
Our Position Is Clear
ObjectNow Is 100% Opposed
ObjectNow is 100% opposed to hyperscale data centre developments of the kind being proposed at Chapelcross.
We believe the environmental impacts, electricity requirements, infrastructure implications and claimed economic benefits of these developments require far greater scrutiny than they often receive in public discussion.
Our limited use of artificial intelligence for technical document processing does not change that position.
Using a technology and supporting the industrial-scale expansion of infrastructure associated with that technology are two very different things.
We will continue to use technology responsibly where it genuinely helps communities, while challenging developments that we believe place unacceptable pressures on the environment, infrastructure and the places people call home.
Our Continuing Commitment
ObjectNow remains committed to independent research, transparency, environmental protection and meaningful public participation in the planning process.

Leave A Comment